Software Review
NetObjects Authoring Server
Suite 2000
NetObjects, Inc.
By Gordon Benett
Most corporate intranets start
life as a jungle of departmental web sites, and some never evolve into
more holistic, manageable systems. But as the amount of content
housed on an intranet grows, and as people become increasingly dependent
on that content for making decisions, the absence of a collaborative
content management process takes a toll both in cost and risk. It's
expensive because having many webmasters who step on each others' pages
is inefficient. And its risky because multiple uncoordinated authors
can as easily overwrite valuable content as upload it.
In 1999 the need to manage intranet content has become obvious as companies
recast themselves as "e-businesses." Accordingly, a market
has developed for web design tools that enforce, or at least encourage
collaboration. NetObjects, Inc. deserves kudos for recognizing this
need ahead of the pack and introducing a solution (see IDM's February
1998 review of TeamFusion 1.0 for details.)
With NetObjects Authoring Server Suite 2000 the company further enhances
the value proposition laid down by two earlier versions. A few
irritating properties of v1.0 still remain, but for many customers they
will pale to invisibility compared with the product's virtues.
Let's take a walk through the suite.
No assembly required
Authoring Server Suite 2000 consists of four components:
- Authoring Server, a heavyweight process that manages site assets
(in a SQL database) as well as developer concurrency
- Authoring Server Administrator, a client process that can run on
any machine that sees the Server
- TeamFusion Client, a web design tool with role-based access control
- Content Contributor, a browser-based client for entering content
remotely
Installing these pieces was not especially pleasant - I had to enter
a 34-character serial number and reboot NT for each - but everything
did work on the first try.
The big server piece installs as an NT service on NT Workstation or
Server. I loaded it onto a Pentium Pro 200 MHz machine running Windows
NT Workstation (sp5) in 128 MB RAM. Thanks to the SCSI-2 disk subsystem
this is a reasonably fast machine - or was, until now (about which more
shortly).
The README.TXT file contains some good notes on multiprocessor performance
tuning, which led me to reduce server threads from the default 2 to
1 (since I was testing under 5 concurrent clients).
I loaded the TeamFusion Client, where actual site development takes
place, onto two machines: the server box and a 400 MHz Pentium II running
NT Server 4.0 in 128 MB ram. At installation you're prompted to create
at least one user with administrative priveleges, after which you can
attach to the Server. I did this, opting to create a new site called
MyIntranet using one of NetObjects' site templates. The result is shown
below.
At
this point I noticed several differences between this and older versions
of Authoring Server. Foremost was performance. The Pentium Pro machine
churned for several minutes as it built the new site. Feedback to
the user could be better during this interval, when it's easy to
lose confidence that things are still working. The other lesson is that
you can't have too much hardware for this product. I'd recommend a 2-CPU
server with 256MB ram for a small workgroup.
The site administrator sets up additional team members, granting them
role-based development privileges that range from contributing
text to full site administration. Users can be set up individually or
imported, along with their authentication data, from an NT domain, Novell
Directory Server or LDAP source. Very enterprise-friendly.
The strong visual design features of the TeamFusion Client have changed
little since the prevous version (which I reviewed
last year). Also present are controls for checking elements in and
out of projects and a WorkGroup Palette that tells all clients who
is working on what.
Perhaps the biggest difference between this and earlier versions is
the presence of workflow features, including:
- Review/Approval Publishing - a review coordinator can designate
one or more team members as Reviewers, requiring explicit approval
before publishing
- Task management - allows assignment of tasks and keeps track of
and communicates task status
- Instant Messaging - allows team members to send messages in real-time,
rather than relying on e-mail.
These features work together to enhance coordination between
stakeholders. For instance, content rejected by a reviewer can be assigned
as a task to the appropriate designer, then re-submitted upon completion,
all without leaving the TeamFusion environment.
In addition, IT managers will find the new release of Authoring Server
a good neighbor to existing design tools. Shops that already use third-party
design tools such as Microsoft FrontPage or Macromedia Dreamweaver can
now manage their output with Authoring Server, thanks to NetObjects'
line of add-on connectors to these tools.
NetObjects also addresses the blurring distinction between intranet
design and application development with a set of integration suites
that couple Authoring Server 2000 to several popular application server
platforms, including IBM WebSphere, Allaire Cold Fusion and Microsoft
Active Server Pages.
Pricing
A 2-client license for NetObjects Authoring Server 2000 is priced at
$1990. Sites over a few dozen pages should factor in the cost of a multi-processor
server with 256 MB ram as well, to cover the suite's hardware hunger.
Authoring Server Suite 3.0 customers get a 25% discount on the upgrade.
At this price point no other team-based web design product
offers a comparable mix of design features, collaborative workflow aids
and extensibility. If you're looking to graduate from desktop publishing
to managed intranet design, you need to look at NetObjects Authoring
Server 2000.
NetObjects Inc.
602 Galveston Drive
Redwood City, CA 94063
Ph: 1-888-449-6400 toll-free or (650) 482-3200
Fx: (650) 562-0288
NetObjects, NetObjects Fusion and TeamFusion
are trademarks of NetObjects, Inc. All other brand or product names
are property of their respective holders.
This
is the third release of NetObjects,
Inc.'s best-in-class collaborative site design suite,
and it doesn't disappoint. The addition of messaging
and workflow features enhances the product's already
strong team support. Site version control provides
a fine-grained rollback capability, while support for symmetrical
multiprocessing (SMP) allows CPU-intensive publishing
to take place without interrupting design. Other new features
include the ability to import users from LDAP or NDS
directories and a task scheduler for automatic
publishing and backups.
Shops
that already use third-party design tools such as
Microsoft FrontPage or Macromedia Dreamweaver can now manage
their output with Authoring Server, thanks to NetObjects'
line of add-on connectors to these tools. Furthermore,
NetObjects addresses the blurring distinction between intranet
design and application development with a set of integration
suites that couple Authoring Server 2000 to several
popular application server platforms, including IBM WebSphere,
Allaire Cold Fusion and Microsoft Active Server Pages.
Value
A 2-client license for NetObjects Authoring Server 2000
costs $1990. No other team-based web design product offers
comparable functionality at this price point.